2 curricula compared

Best Homeschool Reading Curriculum— Honest Comparison

Every Reading curriculum in this guide is reviewed honestly — real strengths, real weaknesses, and who each one actually fits. No affiliate rankings.

Costs as of June 2026 — always verify on the publisher's site.

At a glance

CurriculumPublisherPedagogyCostParent involvementLensAgesRating
All About ReadingAll About Learning PressOrton-Gillingham + multisensory$120-150/year per levelhighSecularPre-K to 44.8
Logic of English EssentialsLogic of Englishphonics + spelling rules$135highSecularK-124.6

In depth

All About Reading

All About Learning Press

4.8
Cost
$120-150/year per level
Pedagogy
Orton-Gillingham + multisensory
Parent involvement
High — parent teaches
Religious lens
Secular
Age range
Pre-K to 4
Time per day
20-30 min
Duration
150 lessons

Strengths

  • Gold standard for struggling readers
  • Multisensory
  • Open-and-go for parent

Weaknesses

  • Pricey
  • Slow pace for fast learners

Best for

Beginning readers, kids with dyslexia

Worst for

Kids who already read fluently

Pricing as of June 2026 — verify on the publisher's site before purchasing.

Logic of English Essentials

Logic of English

4.6
Cost
$135
Pedagogy
phonics + spelling rules
Parent involvement
High — parent teaches
Religious lens
Secular
Age range
K-12
Time per day
30-45 min
Duration
~32 weeks, 160 lessons

Strengths

  • Teaches WHY English spells the way it does
  • Reading + spelling + grammar
  • Works for older struggling readers

Weaknesses

  • Heavy parent prep
  • Dense

Best for

Spelling strugglers, kids who ask 'why'

Worst for

Light-touch families

Pricing as of June 2026 — verify on the publisher's site before purchasing.

Head-to-head comparisons

All About Reading vs Logic of EnglishWhich fits your kid? →

AI tutor

Find a Reading tutor for your homeschooler →

All subjects

← Back to curriculum hub

Compare other subjects

All-in-oneChumashEnglishFrameworkFrenchGermanGrammarHebrewHistoryItalianLatinMathMath + SciencePortugueseScienceScriptureSpanishSpellingWriting
Let us rank it for your kid

Not sure which Reading curriculum fits your family?

Homeschool Factory's curriculum quiz reads your family's learning style, budget, and religious lens — then ranks every curriculum by fit, strongest first.

Start free trial

Curriculum data compiled from publisher websites and homeschool parent communities. Costs and availability verified June 2026 — verify current pricing on each publisher's site before purchasing. No affiliate relationships; no sponsored rankings. THSF house curricula (marked “Included”) are reviewed to the same honest standard as third-party options.

Best Homeschool Reading Curriculum — Honest Comparison | Homeschool Factory